Skip to main content

Roofing Guide

Does my roof need a repair or a replacement?

By All Purpose Anytime Services LLC

Repair it when the roof is sound and one thing failed. Replace it when the shingles are worn out, it leaks in several places or the decking has gone soft. The age on its own does not settle it.

Where it leaks tells you a lot

Most leaks we trace are not in the middle of the shingles. They are at flashing, in valleys, around chimneys and skylights, at pipe boots, and along the eave where ice backed water up under the first course. Those are repairs, on a ten-year-old roof or a thirty-year-old one.

A leak in the open field of an older roof is a different story. When the mat inside the shingle has gone brittle and the granules have washed off, water gets through because the material is finished. No single part failed.

Signs a roof is at the end

Look for a lot of granules in the gutters, shingles that curl at the edges or cup in the middle, bald patches where the mat shows, and shingles that crack when you bend them. A roof that has been repaired in three or four places in a couple of years belongs on the list too.

Architectural shingles in this climate usually last a couple of decades. They go sooner over a badly vented attic, where trapped summer heat cooks the deck and ages the shingle from underneath.

If a new roof is not in the budget yet, read what to do if you can't afford a new roof.

The decking is the part nobody sees

Plywood that has gone soft or come apart in layers lets nails back out, so the shingles nailed into it work loose. You cannot see it from the ground, and often not from the attic either when insulation is in the way.

That is why a replacement estimate should say what happens if bad decking turns up once the tear-off starts. Ours gives a price per sheet up front, so it never shows up later as a surprise.

Storm damage is its own question

Wind and hail damage often goes through insurance first. Whether it can be repaired depends on how much of the roof was hit and whether the shingle is still made in a color that matches.

We document damage from one storm with photos and a written scope for the adjuster. Twenty years of weather is wear, and a contractor who calls it storm damage is setting you up for a denied claim.

The inside of the house

If the roof leaked long enough to stain a ceiling, there is damage inside as well. Soaked insulation flattens and loses its value, and drywall that has been wet more than once stays stained and soft.

We price the roof and the ceiling on one estimate. The company behind this brand mainly does drywall, so a new roof over a stained ceiling is a job we can finish.

One more repair question

Is it better to patch a damaged area or replace the whole slope?

Patch it when the rest of the slope is sound and the damage has a clear edge, like a limb strike or one failed valley. Replace the slope when the shingles around the damage are brittle, cupped or losing granules, because new shingles set among worn ones keep failing where they meet. On a slope that faces the street, a full slope also avoids a patch that looks newer than everything around it.

Get Both Prices

Tell us the age of the roof if you know it. When it is a close call, the repair and the replacement are priced side by side.

We take insurance jobs. Financing may be available for qualifying projects.

Repair or replace? Get both prices

We photograph the roof and price both options side by side, so you can compare them on paper.