Skip to main content

Common Problem

Why are my gutters overflowing?

By All Purpose Anytime Services LLC

Usually it is a clog. When it is not, the gutter is pitched the wrong way, there are too few downspouts for the roof, or the gutter has pulled away from the fascia. Each has its own fix, and only one of them is a new gutter.

1. A clogged gutter or downspout

Leaves, seed pods and shingle granules pack the outlet, the gutter fills, and water spills over the front. Under big trees this happens every fall.

Check the downspout as well as the trough. A blocked downspout makes a clean gutter overflow.

2. The wrong pitch

A gutter has to fall toward its downspout. If it is level or falls the other way, water sits and spills at the low point. Standing water in the gutter a day after rain gives it away.

The pitch can usually be reset by rehanging the run, which is a repair.

3. Too few downspouts

A big roof plane emptying into one long run with one downspout will overflow in a hard rain even when the gutter is clean. Another downspout or a bigger outlet fixes it.

4. The gutter pulling off the fascia

Loose hangers let the gutter sag. Water runs behind it and down the fascia board and rots the wood. If the fascia is soft, we replace it before the gutter goes back up.

Repair or replace?

Repair it when the run is sound and the problem is the pitch, a hanger or a joint. Replace it when the gutter is corroded along its length.

Guards cut down on cleaning, but none of them end it, and cheap ones make a clog harder to clear. Sort the gutter out before deciding on guards.

Why fix it now

Water that spills over the gutter lands against the foundation, and from there it can end up in the basement, which costs a lot more than a gutter. See gutter and roof drainage.

Gutters spilling over?

We check the pitch, the hangers and the downspouts, then tell you whether it is a repair or a replacement.