Roofing Guide
What is the best roofing material?
By All Purpose Anytime Services LLC
For most pitched houses around Washington, the best roofing material is an architectural asphalt shingle. InterNACHI's life expectancy chart gives it about 30 years, against 20 for a 3-tab shingle, and it is what we put on most replacements. Slate lasts longest, 60 to 150 years on the same chart, on a house framed to carry its weight. A flat or low-slope roof needs a membrane, because shingles only shed water on a slope.
Start with the slope of your roof
Shingles, slate and metal panels are made for a pitched roof, where gravity carries the water over each course. A low-slope roof holds water longer, so it gets a continuous membrane with sealed seams. Plenty of DC rowhouses have both: a flat main roof behind a parapet and a small pitched roof over the front bay.
Pitched roofs: shingles, slate and metal
Architectural shingles are two or more layers laminated together, so they are thicker than a 3-tab shingle and carry a higher wind rating. InterNACHI puts them at 30 years and 3-tab at 20. They are what we put on most of the pitched roofs we replace.
Slate is the long-life option, 60 to 150 years on the InterNACHI chart, and it is heavy. Some older DC houses still have it. We point slate work to a slate specialist instead of guessing at it.
Metal is listed at 40 to 80 years. We do not install metal roofs, so if you have settled on metal, a metal roofing specialist is the right call.
Flat and low-slope roofs
The InterNACHI chart lists EPDM rubber at 15 to 25 years, modified bitumen at 20, built-up roofing at 30 and TPO at 7 to 20. On the flat roofs we repair, the field of the membrane is seldom what gives out first. The seams, the edge where the membrane turns up a wall and the drain do.
Which membrane goes on depends on what is there now and what will bond to it, and whether water is ponding. See flat roof repair and patch, coat or replace.
The details decide more than the material
A 30 year shingle over reused flashing will leak at the chimney long before the shingle wears out. In this climate the leaks start at flashing hit by wind-driven rain, valleys full of leaves and eaves where ice backs up. Ice and water shield in the valleys and at the eaves, new flashing and a vented attic are worth more than moving up a shingle grade.
Our estimate names the shingle by product line and says whether each piece of flashing is new or kept, so you can compare quotes on the same terms.
Where the lifespan figures come from
The year figures are from InterNACHI's Standard Estimated Life Expectancy Chart for Homes, looked up in November 2026. They are averages for a roof installed and maintained properly, and the chart calls itself a general guideline. For how a roof's life plays out on a real house, see how long does a roof last.
Material questions
Is a metal roof better than shingles?
It lasts longer on paper: InterNACHI's chart lists metal at 40 to 80 years and architectural shingles at 30. We do not install metal, so we can't price it or speak to how it goes on. If you want metal, ask a metal roofing specialist, and ask them how the flashing at your chimney and walls will be done.
What is the best material for a flat roof?
The one that bonds to what is already there and drains properly, installed with sealed seams and a sound edge. On the InterNACHI chart, built-up roofing is listed at 30 years, modified bitumen at 20, EPDM at 15 to 25 and TPO at 7 to 20. Ponding water shortens any of them.
Are architectural shingles worth it over 3-tab?
For most houses, yes. They are thicker, they generally carry a higher wind rating, and InterNACHI lists them at 30 years against 20 for 3-tab. They are what we install on most replacements, and the estimate names the product line.
Help Me Pick a Roof
Tell us what is on the roof now and whether it is pitched or flat. We look at it and put the material, by product line, on a written price.
We take insurance jobs. Financing may be available for qualifying projects.
Not sure what your roof should get?
We look at the slope, the deck and what is up there now, and the written estimate names the product line.